The Peacemaker Brewster · Cape Cod Order Ahead774-323-0529

The Peacemaker

Peace, love,
sandwiches.

Breakfast till noon. Subs after that. Coffee the whole time.

Open Daily · 7am – 2pm
Order Ahead774-323-0529 See the Menu

What we do

Three good reasons to
stop the car.

A toasted BLT cut in half on a paper plate

Breakfast till noon

Eleven breakfast sandwiches, eggs any style, home fries, and pancakes that showed up new and never left. Served till noon, then it's lunch.

See breakfast
A turkey sub on a seeded roll, cut in half

Subs, wrapped

Seeded roll, wrapped in paper, named after people who mostly never met. The Italian Peacemaker is the one you point at when you can't decide.

See the subs
A tray of glazed and chocolate frosted doughnuts by the counter

Grab-and-go

Doughnuts, muffins, cookies out of the oven, nitro cold brew and iced coffee. Three for the beach, one for the drive.

Find the counter

@peacemakerbrewster

Straight from the feed.

Follow on Instagram
  • Four iced coffees in a carry tray
  • The order counter under an ORDER HERE sign
  • A staff member with an iced coffee beside a handwritten homemade coffee syrup sign
  • The grab-and-go cooler stocked with fruit cups, yogurts and cold drinks
  • Two staff members taking a coffee break behind the counter
  • The shop doorway in autumn, pumpkins along the brick path
  • The Peacemaker roadside sign against a blue summer sky
Two staff behind the counter holding trays of muffins and cookies, with the chalkboard drinks menu behind them

Our story

Named for a peace offering. Made to order.

The name goes back to old New Orleans. As the story goes, husbands who'd spent the night carousing through the French Quarter would buy an outrageously loaded sandwich at sunrise, one big enough to count as an apology, and carry it home to make peace with a wife who'd been waiting up.

By the early 1900s "peacemaker" was already local slang for an overstuffed oyster loaf, showing up in The Picayune's Creole Cook Book in 1901. Some food historians call it a direct ancestor of the po'boy. We just kept the name.

7amCoffee's on
9Menu sections
DailyBaked in-house

What people say

Four and a half stars
on Google.

4.5

Across 103 Google reviews

577
414
33
23
16
Read them on Google
  • They serve 3 Fins coffee here and homemade muffins and out-of-this-world breakfast sandwiches. Our new favorite breakfast stop on the Cape. The staff is all smiling and friendly. This is clearly a well-run business. I’m so glad we stumbled upon it.
    Chelsea Russell3 weeks ago · Google review
  • Easily the best turkey club sub I’ve ever had! Kind girl at the front. The food was made quickly, but not so quickly that it felt slapped together.
    Kay4 months ago · Google review
  • Terrific breakfast and lunch sandwiches, excellent coffee, and sensible prices.
    Google review
  • Awesome food, big portions, excellent pricing and the service super.
    Google review
  • Yummy-looking muffins and homemade dog treats available too!
    Google review

What people mention most

Google pulls these out of the reviews themselves. The number is how many people brought it up.

  • Cozy atmosphere 8
  • Outdoor space 6
  • Muffins 6
  • Steak and cheese 5
  • Sandwiches 5
  • Portuguese sweet rolls 4
  • Home fries 2
  • Iced coffee 2

The short list

Nine sections. Six to start.

Breakfast sandwiches, plates & sides, pancakes, subs, join the club, salads, wraps, simple simons, quesadillas. The whole thing is one page and it loads fast.

See the full menu

Counter favourites

The Italian Peacemaker $14
The Albert Einswine $11
The Local Cheesesteak $15
Mahatma Veggie $10
Pancakes New $8
The Brewster Xpress $5

Find us

2149 Main Street,
Brewster.

Hours

  • Monday – Sunday7:00am – 2:00pm
  • DoughnutsUntil they're gone

Contact

Address 2149 Main St
Brewster, MA 02631
Phone 774-323-0529
Social @peacemakerbrewster

Good to know

  • Outdoor seating
  • Takeout & dine-in
  • Free parking
  • Wheelchair accessible
  • Dogs welcome outside
  • Card & contactless
Get Directions